Building The Pour Report’s Brooklyn Brewery – Pre Design

Seven months have passed since I moved cross country to Brooklyn. Life has a way of getting in the way of hobbies and my new brewery build was shifted to the back burner. Luckily, things are looking up. New equipment has been ordered and my first Brooklyn batch is only a couple weeks out.

Home brewery design has been on my mind a lot. Sizing components, designing wort transfer processes, handling the logistics of boiling on a puny stove and thinking about the items I’d change from my original brewery have been integral to my new brewery’s design. Among things that I wanted to implement in the new design:

  1. Pump transfers of liquid. No more lifting heavy (and hot) vessels.
  2. Use a plate chiller to increase cooling efficiency. Plumb vessels and pump to allow circulation back into kettle post-chill in order to utilize a whirlpool and minimize cold break from getting into the fermenter. It doesn’t appear many people are doing this, and I may abandon the process it if it proves to have little benefit.
  3. Create a tangential inlet into the kettle to allow for effective whirlpools.
  4. Use stainless steel quick disconnects throughout — because they’re cool.
  5. Plan for easy future integration of a RIMS tube w/ PID controller.
  6. Plan for easy future integration of a hop back.
  7. Build the brewery around the smaller volumes that fit the type of brewer I am.
  8. Use an electric heat element to jump start boils. Don’t electrocute myself.

Paramount to my brewery’s design is the volume of the various vessels. It is important to appropriately size my new brewery for the typical volumes and specific gravities I intend to use it for. By analyzing my own personal brewing interests, I’ve come up with the following typical brew lengths which can be used to size my equipment.

Typical Brew Lengths

  1. The Daily Drinker – 3 gallons (post boil) up to 1.080 original gravity.
    Easily packaged in a 3 gallon corny keg and served on draft. Typical brew length.
  2. Experimental Split Batches – 2.5 gallons (post boil) up to 1.120 original gravity.
    The perfect volume for experimentation. Easily split into secondary 1 gallon glass vessels for different treatments. Capable of producing very high gravity wort.
  3. Recipe Development Batches – 1.5 gallons (post boil) up to 1.120 original gravity.
    I get most of my enjoyment from the brewing process and learning about the implications recipe and process design have on the final batch. This batch size and gravity allows for frequent brewdays and flexibility.

Vessel Sizing

The vessels I’ve put into my brewery are designed around the gravity and volume of the typical brew lengths. Of the above scenarios, the ‘Experimental Split Batches’ has the highest gravity demands and thus dictates the mash tun sizing. The calculations showing the mash tun size requirements are below.

Constants Used for Calculations
70% efficiency (batch sparge)
60% efficiency (no sparge)

Mash Thickness: 1.25 qt. / pound water (batch sparge)
Mash Thickness: 2.25 qt. / pound water (no sparge)

35 Gravity Units per Pound of Malt
1 lb grain = 0.32 quarts (volume)
0.15 gallon / pound (grain water absorption)

Sizing Calculations

Experimental Split Batches:
2.5 Gallons @ 1.120 Original Gravity

2.5 x 120 = 300 Gravity Units

Mash Volume Calculation (Batch Sparge):
300 GUs  / 35 PPG / 0.7 (efficiency) = 12.24 lbs grain = 3.92 qt. = 0.98 gallons
3.825 gallons Strike Water @ 1.25 qt/lb

Total mash volume: 4.8 gallons

Mash Volume Calculation (No Sparge):
300 GUs  / 35 PPG / 0.6 (efficiency) = 14.28 lbs grain = 4.57 qt. = 1.14 gallons
8.03 gallons Strike Water @ 2.25 qt/lb

Total mash volume: 9.17 gallons
Kettle volume = 8.03 (strike volume) – 2.14 (grain absorption) – 0.5 (dead space) = 5.39 gallons

Mash Tun Size

Of the brew length typologies above, the ‘Experimental Split Batch’ (batch sparge) requires the largest volume mash tun (9.17 gallons). At the last NHC I won a 42 quart Polar Ware stainless steel kettle which should work well as a mash tun once it is insulated. It is stainless steel which will allows me to heat my strike water directly in the mashtun, and possibly do some direct fired mashes with the aid of a pump and stirring action. This is a large mash tun and will likely be problematic for extremely small batches. My plan is to design my hot liquor tank with valves, a false bottom, and insulation so that it may be used as an alternative mash tun for small batches.

Hot Liquor Tank Size

Strike water will be directly heated in the mashtun. When batch sparging, a separate 3-gallon vessel will be used to heat sparge water.

Kettle Size

My maximum batch size is 3 gallons. If these batches start with 3.5-4 gallons of volume  pre-boil, I should be able to use a 5-gallon boil kettle. For batches requiring very high gravities, I will likely run off more wort than can fit in this kettle and boil for long periods. In this case, I will likely split the boil into multiple vessels.

For my next post, I’ll photograph the brewery’s test run and breakdown the parts and processes designed into the brewery. In the meantime, check out the sketches of the brewery’s main components used to determine how everything connects and works together.

42 Quart Stainless Steel Mashtun. Features SS false bottom, ported thermometer, and SS quick disconnects.

Mash: 42 quart stainless steel mash tun. Features SS false bottom, ported thermometer, and stainless steel quick disconnects.

5-Gallon stainless steel kettle. Features two liquid ports (one out and one in for whirlpool functions), a sight glass with thermometer, and additional heat supply via a bucket heater.

Boil: 5-Gallon stainless steel kettle. Features two liquid ports (one ‘out’ and one ‘in’ for whirlpool functionality), a sight glass with thermometer, and supplemental heat source via a bucket heater.

March pump with stainless steel quick disconnects. There is a tee with valves allowing recirculating directly into kettle or through the plate chiller that is attached in series.

Wort Transfer: March pump with stainless steel quick disconnects. There is a tee with valves allowing for recirculation directly into kettle or through the plate chiller that is attached in series.

Plate chiller with appropriate stainless steel quick disconnect fittings.

Chill: Plate chiller with appropriate stainless steel quick disconnect fittings. Polysulfone quick discounts connect the chiller to my cold water source (my kitchen faucet).

All hoses are designed with appropriate food safe thermo-plastics and stainless steel quick disconnects where possible.

All hoses are designed with appropriate food safe thermo-plastics and stainless steel quick disconnects where possible.

New Belgium / Alpine Super IPA Review

New Belgium / Alpine Super IPA

New Belgium / Alpine Super IPA

The nature of the craft beer movement encourages trends. Currently, it seems that collaboration beers are all the rage. Stone does it all the time (even with homebrewers) as does Russian River, Deschutes, Hair of the Dog, and many of the greatest breweries in the country. Super IPA is a collaboration between one of the biggest craft brewers (New Belgium) and one of the smallest and most sought after (Alpine Beer Co.). At first glance, this seems like an amazing opportunity for a small and critically-acclaimed brewery to get distribution well-beyond their typical geographical influence. Unfortunately, while quaffable, this beer misses on many marks which would have made it amazing.

Beer Data:

Purchased: 10/5/12 at Whole Foods P Street, Washington DC
Consumed: 10/7/12
Bottled: No decipherable date on bottle
Alcohol: 9% ABV

Commercial Description from Website:

The Alpine Beer Co. and New Belgium have come together for the love of IPAs. This collaboration is hop-wonderful with Amarillo, Columbus, Simcoe and Centennial hops, bringing the bitter all the way to the front. A nice balance is present with Pale, C-80 and Carapils malts, but the tropical and citrus tones of the American hops dominate. This Super IPA pours a sheened copper and carries a bright, white head. Consider yourself a hero for getting an  Alpine beer outside of San Diego.

Tasting Notes:

Aroma: Big green grassy raw hop aroma. Hops are quite resinous and herbal. This beer is dominated by Columbus hops, which are very rough around the edges. There are some nice mango and tropical fruit notes which seem bullied by the heavy piney and grassy characters. Little to no malt aromas are present on the nose; quite characteristic of Alpine’s other offerings. This beer smells like homebrewed beers I’ve had that sat too long on the dry hop. 5 / 12

Appearance: Very light copper bordering on golden. Off-white head with great retention. Clear, but not crystal clear. 3 / 3

Flavor: Big grassy raw hop flavor. Lots of resin on the palette. The flavor is pretty one-dimensional and dominated by the grassy / herbal hop flavor. There is a very light sweetness / honey character to the malt, but it is by no means easily perceived. This is a very smooth beer whose bitterness is quite low for the style, but balances with the dryness of the beer. This is where I see Alpine’s biggest influence.  11 / 20

Mouth Feel: Medium / medium low body. Average carbonation. Some astringency reminiscent of chewing on a raw hop pellet. 4 / 5

Overall Impression: Alpine is known for producing over-the-top hoppy beers with huge tropical fruit flavors and very lean malt profiles. I feel like this beer tried to hit those notes, but fell short in the hop selection arena. I can’t help but think that perhaps the need to produce New Belgium scale quantities of this beer forced the hand of the brewers into compromising on their hop selection; using massive quantities of Columbus hops which come off harsh, grassy and herbal in this beer rather than the more tropical varietals like Amarillo and Simcoe listed on New Belgium’s website. The malt is perfectly in line with Alpine’s tradition; dry and lean which would set the stage perfectly for a cleaner, fruitier hop experience. Unfortunately, this is where it falls short. 5 / 10

Score: 28 / 50 (Good)

Note: Evaluation done according to BJCP Scoring System. This beer was reviewed as a Category 14c. Imperial IPA.

The Best of 2012 (According to this Guy)

This time of the year is awash in bloggers writing about the best things they discovered over the previous year. While somewhat self-indulgent (yes, I’ll admit it), it’s a fun way to look back over the course of the previous year, reflect upon what you have done, and really think about the moments that wowed you.

2012 was a banner year of sorts. It was my first time attending the National Homebrewers Conference, I moved across the country from Seattle to Brooklyn, and I started this blog. Plenty of memories were made and many more were fuzzied by delicious beers.

Without further adieu, my…

Best Beer Fest: Cask Beer Fest, Seattle, WA
I attended seven beer festivals this year including the biggest one in the country, GABF. There are huge differences between the fests I’ve attended in Seattle and those held in Brooklyn. In Seattle, the booths are staffed with brewery representatives who strive to bring interesting and seasonal beers; something I’ve found lacking so far with NYC events. The epitome of this was Cask Fest held last March at Seattle Center. The venue is great, the brewers brought an excellent variety of cask ales, and the crowd was friendly and enthusiastic. It was easily my favorite fest of 2012. Hopefully in 2013 I’ll discover some east coast fests striving for equally high standards.

Best Session Beer: Happy Hops, Russian River Brewing Company, Santa Rosa, CA
At 5.5% ABV this hoppy pale ale pushes the limit of what some would consider to be sessionable. I tend to disagree since for me, the biggest key to making a session beer is keeping the beer light enough to consume in quantity while maintaining enough depth of flavor to keep you going back. Happy Hops is layered with many levels of hop flavor and aroma making it a beer that continues to evolve as you drink. The malt is crisp and slightly toasty, but has very little caramel or sweet malt flavors which tend to become heavy.

Best Brewpub Experience: Ladyface Ale Companie, Agoura Hills, CA
Classy decor, friendly staff, and a wide variety of delicious beers made for a great time at Ladyface. The only downside was their strip mall location.

Most Memorable Beer: Selinsgrove Barrel Aged Wee Heavy, Selinsgrove, PA
Like manna from heaven, this beer was placed in front of me on the last day of my cross-country brewery tour. I tried many, many beers on this road trip; this beer stands heads above the others. It was complex, slightly smoky, full bodied and creamy, and had tons of vanilla. Perhaps I have a soft-spot for scotch ales placed into barrels, but this beer was absolutely marvelous.

HGSP Booth at NHC

HGSP Booth at NHC

Best Event: The National Homebrewers Conference, Seattle, WA
Yes, it was pretty awesome winning a Gold Medal in the National Homebrew Conference. Even better, however, were the great friendships that were solidified, new friends that were made, and information that was learned. I am especially proud of the awesome booth the Homebrewers Guild of Seattle Proper built and the amazing job we did serving really good beers.

Top 5 Beers (Since Arriving on the East Coast)
There were so many outstanding beers made in 2012 that it is tough to narrow it down to 5. In order to make my task easier, here are the top 5 I’ve had since relocating to Brooklyn. The East Coast and Brooklyn, in particular, gets distribution of some really awesome beers I previously didn’t have access to. This list is quite evocative of my taste for hoppy or barrel aged beers.

  1. Founders Backwoods Bastard
  2. Troegs Perpetual IPA
  3. Ithaca Flower Power
  4. Goose Island Bourbon County Stout
  5. Founders Breakfast Stout

In 2013, I look forward to brewing again and writing about the expolits here–hopefully in a more steady fashion. Here’s hoping that 2013 is as good, or even better, for all of you!

Craft Beer Road Trip – A Photo Recap

Gallery

This gallery contains 57 photos.

Moving became an excellent excuse to do a cross-country brewery tour hitting some of the best America has to offer. This was a no-brainer for a beer-geek like me. All in all, we (my wife, myself, and our two pugs) made it to twenty-one breweries: HUB (Portland, OR) Lagunitas (Petaluma, CA) Russian River Brewing (Santa Rosa, CA) Anchor Brewing (San Francisco, CA) 21st Amendment (San Francisco, CA) Firestone Walker Brewing Co. (Paso Robles, CA) Creekside Brewing Co. (San Luis Obispo, CA) Lengthwise Brewing Co. (Bakersfield, CA) Kern River Brewing Co. (Kernville, CA) The Bruery (Placentia, CA) Squatters Pub Brewery (Salt Lake City, UT) New Belgium Brewing (Fort Collins, CO) Odell … Continue reading